Judge dismisses case over FBI raid of 1,400 private safe-deposit boxes and seizure of millions in jewelry and cash

2022-10-10 14:31:27 By : Ms. Sephcare Wang

A judge has ruled the March 2021 FBI raid of US Private Vaults did not violate the Fourth Amendment.

Deposit-box holders whose property was seized in the raid and has not been returned sued the bureau.

A lawyer involved in the class action said the raid was the "largest armed robbery in US history."

A judge ruled on September 29 that federal agents who raided 1,400 safe-deposit boxes in March 2021 at a private vault company did not violate search and seizure laws, court documents shared with Insider show.

A lawsuit filed in August alleged the FBI and the US attorney's office in Los Angeles obtained warrants against US Private Vaults in Beverly Hills, California, by concealing critical details from the judge who approved them.

In his ruling, District Court Judge R. Gary Klausner found no impropriety in the way the government got or executed the warrants for the raid. He dismissed the class-action suit filed on behalf of the people whose boxes had been seized.

The vault company was shut down following the raid and pleaded guilty to conspiracy to launder drug money.

Laura Eimiller, a spokesperson for the FBI, told Insider: "Today's District Court ruling makes it clear that agents investigating criminal activity at US Private Vaults did not mislead the court and affirms the FBI's position that the investigation was conducted without malice and in a manner consistent with the law, FBI policies and the US Constitution."

The lawsuit was filed after FBI agents raided the Beverly Hills branch of US Private Vaults, seizing more than $86 million in cash, as well as jewelry and gold from 1,400 safe-deposit boxes. It said owners' items still had not been returned and that agents misled a judge to get the warrant.

None of the people who owned the boxes has been charged after almost five years of investigating; various agencies concluded "the problem was the business itself," court documents said.

Regarding the unreturned items, Eimiller said that agents "outlined evidence of widespread criminal wrongdoing in court filings while establishing a simple procedure to return safeguarded contents to box holders who were not otherwise subject to asset forfeiture."

Robert Frommer, a lawyer representing at least 400 plaintiffs in the class-action suit, said in an earlier filing that the government "did not know what was in those boxes, who owned them, or what, if anything, those people had done."

"The scope of what the FBI did is unprecedented," Frommer said. "This was the largest armed robbery in United States history, and it was committed by the FBI."

In new emails with Insider, Frommer confirmed that they intended to appeal the ruling.

Rob Johnson, an attorney who works with Frommer, described the ruling as a "shocking decision" that "will set a dangerous precedent that will allow the FBI and other law enforcement agencies to bypass the Fourth Amendment.

"The decision will give a blueprint for the government to pry open safe-deposit boxes, storage lockers, and other private spaces," he said, "and to take the contents with civil forfeiture."

Johnson added: "There is no question that we will be filing an appeal."

"FBI stands by its ongoing investigation of US Private Vaults," Eimiller said, "a business that criminally facilitated drug trafficking and money laundering, and which allowed customers to store their criminal proceeds anonymously in safe-deposit boxes."

According to the court papers, US Private Vaults solicited criminal clientele on its website, saying the less it knew about its customers, the better. The company advertised its services to help customers "avoid 'government agencies (such as the IRS) or attorneys armed with court orders.'"

Documents also said US Private Vaults did not rent solely to criminal customers and many customers used its services for legitimate reasons.

Read the original article on Business Insider

The attack took place outside of the family's Memphis home. The two children were found dead at the scene.

Officers received a call from residents of the house in the 4700 block of 18th Avenue Northeast after they were awakened by the man at 5 a.m.

Sam Wild, 38, left the victim scarred for life following the attack in Sheffield.

The stolen bag also had student papers to be graded.

It’s uncomfortably predictable that Dave Yost will ferociously protect predators and inflict harm on Ohio’s women and girls, Michaela Burriss writes.

Authorities in Chatham County, Georgia, wrapped up a fourth day of searching unsuccessfully for missing 20-month-old Quinton Simon, but authorities still hope

An Oregon serial rapist is set to be released from prison in mid-December after serving nearly 36 years behind bars, almost all of his maximum sentence. Richard Gillmore, arrested in 1986 and called the “jogger rapist” because he staked out victims as he ran by their homes, admitted to raping nine girls in the Portland area in the 1970s and 80s but was only convicted in one case because of the statute of limitations. In 1987, a jury found him guilty of raping 13-year-old Tiffany Edens, his last known victim, in December 1986.

A malnourished victim apparently broke free from a home early Friday morning, screaming for neighbors to help her, police said. One person has been arrested and charged.

The driver returned fire after two or three men unleashed at least a half-dozen rounds into the car, police said.

A missing businessman from Harmony was found dead in the Allegheny River in Pittsburgh’s North Shore on Saturday.

A man is wanted after using a mouse trap to steal checks from a dropbox in Whitehaven, according to the Memphis Police Department.

A Texas police officer has been fired after body cam footage captured him shooting a teenager who was eating a hamburger in a McDonald's parking lot.

The Los Angeles Police Department arrested 34-year-old Clayton Randolph and 35-year-old Shanika Davidson for the violent robbery outside of an Encino gas station.

The Mississippi daycare worker apologized after being fired for taunting and chasing children around the classroom.

Scott Crull resigned from the Richmond Police Department after pleading guilty to a misdemeanor.

Victims of a quick series of stabbings on the Las Vegas Strip described the shock and horror of the unexpected attack on a group of showgirls and others outside a casino that left two people dead and six injured. Police arrested Yoni Barrios, 32, after a short chase blocks from where they say he attacked four showgirls and ended up stabbing eight people on Thursday. An arrest report released Friday said Barrios told police some of the victims had laughed at him and he “let the anger out.”

A woman named Kathy and her daughter told the LA Times the murder suspect robbed them at gunpoint in their garage in 2005.

When the guard spotted two armed men in masks, he stepped in to help.

Rep. Don Bacon (R-Neb.) on Sunday defended Sen. Tommy Tuberville (R-Ala.) after the senator said Democrats want reparations for minorities because their party is “pro-crime.” Bacon told guest host Kristen Welker on NBC’s “Meet the Press” that he “wouldn’t say it the same way” but that politicians should be “honest that we have a crime…

A Georgia inmate inside a maximum security lock-up is accused of impersonating California billionaire movie mogul Sidney Kimmel to steal $11 million in a heist conducted behind bars.